Maximise your Avios, air miles and hotel points

Off topic: Sainsbury’s guts Nectar earning from April 2015

Links on Head for Points may support the site by paying a commission.  See here for all partner links.

I don’t cover Nectar much on Head for Points because it offers little in the way of travel rewards.  I have written about the ability to use your points to book easyJet flights and how the Nectar estore is the only way of getting cashback on an easyJet booking.

I also reviewed the American Express Nectar credit card last year.  This is currently a pretty good deal – no fee for the first year and £100 of Nectar points for signing up.  Amex has tightened up on who can apply, though, and you only get the £100 if you have NO American Express-issued Amex cards at all.

I have also written about how I use Nectar to (indirectly) convert my Amex Membership Rewards points into John Lewis / Waitrose vouchers.  I also covered whether it is better to take Nectar points or Flying Club miles when booking on Virgin Trains.

That is about it.  Here is the new news.

Sainsbury announced yesterday that it is halving its Nectar earning rate from April 2015.  You will earn only 1 point per £1 spent rather than 2 points.  Details can be found on the Sainsbury website here.

This halves your cashback from 1% to 0.5%.

Sainsbury is clearly doing this to cut costs, confident that Nectar is not a sufficient enough attraction to shoppers to cause them to defect in droves.  It is also ending the practice of giving you an extra Nectar point if you use your own bags – it is bringing in a charge for carrier bags instead.

The announcement implies that change is also coming to the Nectar credit card issued by Sainsbury’s Bank:

Nectar is changing for all Sainsbury’s customers, which means that the way our Bank customers collect points when they use their Nectar card in store will change in the future too.

Note that the American Express-issued Nectar card is not impacted.

This is unlikely to signify the end of Nectar in the UK (which, few people know, is owned by the Canadian company which runs Air Canada’s Aeroplan loyalty scheme) but it will be a serious blow.

The problem with Nectar, as I see it, is that it isn’t fun.  It isn’t interesting.  You can’t ‘game’ it.  To all intents and purposes your points are worth 0.5p each and it is hard to improve on that.

Tesco Clubcard, on the other hand, is fun.  You can ‘game’ it and you have sites like this one which spend lots of time explaining how and showing you ways to run up points at minimal cost.  It has a level of customer interaction and involvement that Nectar could never dream of getting.

This is, of course, the same appeal of airline schemes.  Every time I write about a new way of earning or spending Avios points, I am effectively writing a big free advertisement for British Airways / IAG.  Poor old Nectar gets left behind.

Comments (52)

This article is closed to new comments. Feel free to ask your question in the HfP forums.

  • Mr Bridge says:

    Do you think we will will look back over the past few years, and think as a golden age for points?
    In 2012, I sold my business and retired at 46, I then made an effort to look at all of my credit cards and points, ( and some odd surveys i was doing for little cash)and decided to to collect everything avios. A search on google for ‘free avios’ helped me stumble on HFP, one months after it launched.
    Since then when my avios balance was 26,000 with only one redemption for the london eye, I have collected over 800,000, and redeemed 350,000.
    To me , with guidance from HFP, this has been all too easy ( i concede i have a lot of time), but as someone that has always enjoyed luxury travel I have saved £000’s.

    Thanks ROB!

  • Dave Stringer says:

    I blame Aldi.

    I really hope Tesco don’t follow.

    • Frenske says:

      How can you blame Aldi or the Lidl? Because of them Sainsbury and Tesco are forced to keep their prices low. I rather save £25 or more on my monthly shopping. If it costs me 250 Avios I have no problem with it.

      • whiskerxx says:

        Sainsbury and Tesco do not have low prices.
        If people could find the time to stand back and analyse what really happens in store I think most would be quite shocked. Derren Brown would be hard pushed to beat some of the deception that takes place. Tesco exploit the fact that the majority of customers shop with speed and convenience in mind e.g. a bag of “ready to eat” Bananas weighing c750g costs a round £1. But the loose (and ready to eat) bananas on the adjacent fixture cost 68p per kilo. A bag of 4 of “the finest” baking potatoes costs £1.75. A bag of four baking potatoes in Aldi costs 59p. I’m turning into a geek! With lots of time on my hands I do spend a fair amount of time in supermarkets observing strategy and customer behaviours.

        • Andrew S says:

          I totally agree with you.

          What is missed by many is that the quality of most things in Aldi/Lidl is far and away better than the supermarkets… The aldi champagne is excellent at £10 a bottle, the ground coffee is good, bread is great for a basic loaf and lasts for days.. Lidl veg is waitrose standard.

          Sure there is no finest ready meals, but then thats not what i buy anyway!

  • JQ says:

    The problem with nectar is that it has always been effectively devalued relative to clubcard, by a factor of 2, which is a psychological problem when you want to build loyalty

    To add further isult, the earning rates are also devalued:
    You get 1 clubcard = 2p, 3p, maybe 4p for re-using 1 bag, whereas nectar gives you 0.5p
    For petrol Tesco gives you 1 clubcard per £, (so 2/3/4% off) while nectar gives you 1 point per litre (0.3% off)

    When I have to shop in Sainsbury’s, I feel that if I don’t use nectar I am losing money, actual money, since that is basically all nectar is good for. Since you should avoid using clubcard to get money off in Tesco, I thnk of it as spending 1p per £ to buy something worth 2p (or probably 1.5p for avios so I don’t feel ripped off when using avios for poorer value redemptions)

    • Mr Bridge says:

      tesco actually gibe i cc point per £2

      • Roger says:

        No, it’s 1 CC point per £ for shopping at Tesco, the comparison here.

        You may be confusing this with earnings on the Tesco credit card, which for some people is 1 CC point per complete £2 outside Tesco, for most others 1 point per complete £4..

        • Frenske says:

          Tesco Petrol earns 1 CC per £2. At least according to the recipe.

          • Roger says:

            OK, I earn 1 CC point per £ for fuel.

            Tesco’s earning rates are clouded in mystery and AFAIK there’s no webpage showing earning rates for ALL collectors. For example, some grandfathered rates are not shown online.

            How do I get 1 CC point per £? By using my Tesco World Mastercard as a Clubcard. 🙂 (I usually use another card to pay.)

      • JQ says:

        It’s 1cc per £ if you use tesco bank card as clubcard then another card to pay.

    • Darren says:

      Although for the ‘spend points in store’ collector (Who never used clubcard boost) both schemes have been relatively equal, possibly with Nectar being slightly better as you could spend point directly off the card in Argos etc., wonder how they’ll feel about the changes?

  • Erico1875 says:

    I link Tescos demise in the past few years starting from when they cut the usual rate from to 2 to 1 in store and halfed it at the Pump.it was like s mugging for your typical collector.
    Sainsburys are making the same mistake. Although Nectar is not as exciting, I have heard it is still the UKs biggest loyalty scheme.

    • callum says:

      While I think the fact you didn’t realise the standard rate was always 1 per pound, and the 2 per pound was just a temporary promotion, shows you don’t really follow the scheme closely enough to be able to judge whether it “caused their demise”!

      • Erico1875 says:

        How can you know what I know based on a quick comment on a blog?Thats what I THINK helped towards their demise

        Yes ,it may have “officially” been 1 but people were getting 2 for a long while, so it becomes the norm in most normal peoples eyes

  • Sam wardill says:

    It amazes me that Sainsbury have not realised how much value Clubcard delivers for Tesco in attracting high spending customers. It does this, as Rob points out, by being fun. Tesco can afford to invest in Clubcard because it delivers value for them. Nectar could do the same for Sainsbury if they tried a bit harder. Unfortunately I doubt any Sainsburys executives read HFP.

  • Jason says:

    Sainsburys was the most convenient supertstore where I used to live, tesco wasn’t convenient to get to, there was also a fairly accessible Asda.
    However 90% of our shopping was done at tesco purely because of clubcard, and when I found out where 3v cards were sold I drove to a tesco superstore and filled up with diesel and bought 3v cards.
    Where we live now tesco is the most convenient I haven’t even bothered to find out if there’s a sainsburys local, says it all IMO!

  • Rich says:

    I got the email notifying me of this change yesterday. One miniscule positive included a “10x bonus points on fuel event after the change” which, if I interpret it correctly, means it might be worth filling up at Sainsburys for 30 days from April 11th next year when the changes kick in.

    It also mentioned “more bonus points events across the store” which is sufficiently ambiguous to mean anything.

    • Erico1875 says:

      Thats what it needs to be sexy with “points collectors” , BONUS POINTS !!!
      . The 10x points for fuel looks promising.

    • Chrism says:

      Yeah, I received a flyer in the mail about it yesterday and it mentions bonus points and new double ups. It was pretty ambiguous and didn’t give much away.

      I’ll have a better look at it tonight when I get home from work, that’s if the other half hasn’t binned it

  • Simmo says:

    Lets hope that this prompts the likes of eBay to offer Tesco points instead!

This article is closed to new comments. Feel free to ask your question in the HfP forums.

The UK's biggest frequent flyer website uses cookies, which you can block via your browser settings. Continuing implies your consent to this policy. Our privacy policy is here.