Hilton lifetime status launched – how does it compare?

In December I told you that Hilton had been dropping hints that ‘Lifetime Diamond’ status would soon be available.  Hyatt, Marriott and Starwood already have lifetime status schemes of their own so it was not surprising that Hilton chose to follow.

The scheme has now been launched.  Let’s see how it compares with the competition.

Hilton Diamond 350

Hilton HHonors Lifetime Diamond status will not be for feint hearted!

To earn it, you will need to achieve:

10 years, not necessarily consecutive, of Hilton Diamond status

1,000 paid nights

This is confirmed on the Hilton website here.

There is no easy way of telling from the Hilton website how many lifetime nights you have earned.  People are being contacted in batches, it seems, so if you have not received an email yet then it still might turn up.

Let’s compare this to what is on offer elsewhere:

Hyatt Gold Passport offers Lifetime Diamond (top tier) status to anyone who has earned 1 million base points. This would require $200,000 of spending. You must also have been a Hyatt Gold Passport member for 10 years.

Marriott Rewards offers lifetime status across all three elite levels of its programme. It openly publishes the requirements online:

Lifetime Silver requires 250 nights and 1.2 million points

Lifetime Gold requires 500 nights and 1.6 million points

Lifetime Platinum requires 750 nights and 2 million points

Starwood Preferred Guest is the only scheme to reward a long period of ‘middling’ (for want of a better word) loyalty.  The Starwood Lifetime Gold offer is better than the Marriott Lifetime Silver target, because even if you hit the Marriott nights target you are still likely to fall short on points unless your stays are generally high value ones.

Lifetime Starwood Gold status is available if you have stayed 250 nights and had Gold or Platinum status for at least five (not necessarily consecutive) years

Lifetime Starwood Platinum status is available if you have stayed 500 nights and had Platinum status for at least 10 years

As you can obtain Starwood Gold status for free with American Express Platinum – for as long as you keep your Platinum card – this offer is less valuable. Starwood Gold is also available via the Starwood Preferred Guest American Express card if you spend £15,000 per annum.

Doing a line by line comparison:

Hyatt – Hilton Lifetime Diamond is easier to achieve than Hyatt Lifetime Diamond, where you need to have spent $200,000.  Your 1,000 Hilton nights probably cost less than this and there are substantially more Hilton properties around.

Marriott – on the face of it, Marriott Lifetime Platinum is easier to achieve because you only need 750 nights.  However, the requirement to ALSO earn 2 million Marriott points means that most people would need more nights than that as total base spend of $133,000 is needed.  I would say that the two targets are about equal in reality.

Starwood – 500 nights for Lifetime Platinum and 10 years of top-tier membership is clearly a far lower target than Hilton Lifetime Diamond.  The only issue is the far smaller Starwood footprint which might make staying those 500 nights tough.

As I wrote in December, lifetime status with airline or hotel chains has never appealed to me. I would be happy to accept it as a by-product of stays I was doing anyway but would not chase it. Ask the former ‘Lifetime Gold’ members of bmi Diamond Club if it was worth spending money chasing that status, which BA promptly scrapped after the takeover.

It can even create perverse incentives. I have a friend who is close to Lifetime Gold status with British Airways – it is explained here at ba.com if you want to know more about it. As soon as he reaches it he intends to abandon BA on long-haul for what he considers ‘better’ airlines. If Lifetime Gold did not exist he would definitely continue to put 1,500 tier points a year in BA’s direction in order to retain Galleries First access on short-haul.

(Want to earn more hotel points?  To see our complete list of promotions from the major chains, click here to visit our ‘Hotel Promos’ page or use the link in the menu bar at the top of the page.)

Bits: BA returns to Birmingham, £4.20 off a train ticket, new Hyatt status benefits
100 free Clubcard points (240 Avios, 250 Virgin miles) for your insurance renewal dates
About Head for Points

We help business and leisure travellers maximise their Avios, frequent flyer miles and hotel loyalty points. Visit every day for three new articles or sign up for our FREE emails via this page or the box to your right.

Comments

  1. I wonder if fake Diamond status acquired from say Centurion will count towards qualification?

  2. Last 14 years straight as Diamond according to HHonors CS but a long way off the nights qualification as mostly 1 night stays around the UK. Awaiting a reply from HH as to how many I actually have.

  3. I’m diamond at the moment and will probably be diamond next year but I haven’t really noticed any difference since going from gold to diamond.
    I still rate the program more than club Carlson and IHG simply because there is a tangible benefit of free breakfast with Hilton. I’m gold with club Carlson and platinum with IHG, neither of which offer any real benefit! Concierge with club Carlson is impossible to get unless you really do stay a lot of nights with them and IHG just leave it off the list of benefits completely.
    I’d happily strive towards life time gold/diamond at Hilton just to save £20/30 a night for breakfast for 2 on all my future stays.

    • Think Square says:

      Club Carlson status-matched my Hilton Gold. Perhaps I was lucky but I’ve had one stay with them and was treated REALLY well. I was very impressed. I would switch allegiances if they had more UK properties.

      As for Hilton Diamond, I’m probably up to 5 or 6 years in total (I tend to flip-flop between Gold and Diamond), but I have no chance of reaching 1000 nights. That’s 3 years of your life spent in a Hilton!

      • Agreed. I got a good Business Room upgrade at the Radisson Blu Hamburg Airport 18 months ago (the last stay I did). Once you’re in a Business Room you automatically get free breakfast, a free Nespresso machine in the room and free pay-tv.

        • Ditto for me about four months ago at the same property – on a rate prepaid by another company running the course that included breakfast (and no points as I wasn’t paying for it) but appreciated the upgrade! Very good airport hotel, just a couple of minutes walk!

  4. I didn’t requalify for gold this year, but they sent me an email saying I had.

    Quite confusing.