How does BA First Class really compare to Emirates or Etihad? (Part 1)

This is my review of British Airways First Class, between Beijing and London Heathrow.

There is a saying, which I think originated at US blog One Mile At A Time, that British Airways First Class is “the best business class product on the market”.

I recently ran reviews of Emirates A380 First Class and Etihad’s A380 First Class Apartment.  Flying back from Beijing last month, I also got to spend 12 hours in British Airways First Class.  This was a day flight and, coming just a few weeks after my Middle East flights, gave me a good opportunity to see how BA really compares.

It is not a complete defeat for British Airways.  You will remember that I had some issues with both the Emirates product (dated) and Etihad product (too big).  There are elements of BA’s approach which I like, although arguably they are related to ‘Britishness’ which is why unsurpringly the Middle Eastern airlines don’t copy them.

Boarding

I won’t discuss the lounge at Beijing, which is easily the worst dedicated First Class lounge I have ever used!  The fish pond was the only plus point:

British Airways lounge Beijing

You can’t blame British Airways for this, unless it turns out that there are better lounges which BA refuses to fund.

Boarding looked like it would be a mess, since it appeared that 30% of the passengers qualified for priority boarding.  Queuing behind 50 other people was not much of a premium experience, but luckily a staff member was combing the line and pulling out First Class passengers.

Boarding generally works well on BA.  First Class passengers will be given an escort from the door to their seat.  The classical soundtrack in the cabin works well and gives what I think is the correct ambiance.

Despite recent grumblings, I found the cabin was spotlessly clean.  Tara, who was working our side of the cabin (my wife and son were on the other side) was exceptionally polite and good with my 9-year old daughter.

I was given a sleeper suit and a toiletries bag.  I’ve come to like the contents of the British Airways First Class bags.   The mini shaving creams and roll-on deodorants are genuinely useful for future trips.  I just missed out getting the new Liberty bag design by a few days.

Whilst nowhere near as good as the Armani goodies that I got from Qatar Airways First Class last year – I was using the EDT for months – BA was better than the Etihad ‘pick your own’ and Emirates ‘we don’t do bags on day flights’ approach.

Qatar Airways has also downgraded their First Class toiletries offering in recent months.  I’m not sure why these bags are no longer priorised by airlines as I can’t believe that they can’t find willing luxury goods partners to underwrite the cost in return for the exposure.

The newspaper selection on board consisted of China Daily and, erm, that’s it.  I will give BA the benefit of the doubt here and assume that the Chinese do not allow them to hand out imported newspapers.

Unlike Etihad, there was not a personal letter from the Cabin Services Director waiting for me on my seat, neatly rolled and sealed!

The seat

Ah, the seat.  Where do you start?

The Boeing 777, as with the A380 and 747, has a 14-seat First Class cabin.  This is the same as Emirates has on their A380 aircraft, whereas Etihad has only nine ‘apartments’.  I can’t complain about the number of seats, though, because there is no way I could have secured four Avios seats if the cabin had been smaller.  The new British Airways 787-9 fleet has only eight First Class seats.

With a 1-2-1 layout, it is true that British Airways First now looks like ‘the best business class product on the market’.  1-2-1 is, after all, the same layout as used by Qatar Airways, Finnair and – for goodness sake – Aer Lingus in their business class cabins.

This is a library picture of the (slightly larger) A380 version of the seat which is better than any photo I could take:

British Airways First Class review

… and for the middle pair (this is the 787-9 Dreamliner version):

British Airways First Class middle pair

It is, without doubt, nicely done.  You get the classy decoration around the windows:

British Airways First Class review

and little touches like the seat light are attractive:

British Airways First Class review

and, bizarrely, they also have probably the classiest seat control of any aircraft in the sky – you turn it left or right to turn the seat into a bed and back again:

British Airways First Class review

British Airways does this sort of thing well – taking tiny details and creating something which gently oozes style.  The Emirates and Etihad First Class seats do not ooze class in the same way.  There is a feel of ‘Britishness’ to it, with something of the feel of a high end car.

One difference between the BA First Class seats and, say, Qatar Airways business class is that your feet do not end up in a cubby-hole under the seat in front.

In terms of hard numbers, however, it doesn’t look too promising.  According to SeatGuru, you have:

BA First – 78″ pitch, 22″ width

Qatar Airways A380 Business – 80″ pitch, 22″ width

Etihad A380 Business – 73″ pitch, 20″ width

Emirates A380 Business – 70″-79″ pitch, 18″ width

Emirates A380 First – 78″ pitch, 23″ width

Aer Lingus Business – 78″ pitch, 22″ width (taken from Aer Lingus website)

If you want seat space, you’ll get more of it in Qatar Airways A380 business class – albeit your feet will be under the seat in front.  Amazingly, the new A330 Business Class seats on BA’s sister airline, Aer Lingus, promise an identical seat size to British Airways First.  (We are planning to review this seat in detail in September.)

It is worth noting that, whilst the window seats in BA First have more privacy, you get more personal space in the two centre seats.

Unlike Emirates and Etihad, there is no ‘at seat’ mini-bar.  I have never been a big fan of these, primarily because they only tend to contain sugary fizzy drinks and are not chilled.

There are no doors on the British Airways seat.  Etihad’s Apartment, of course, is a mini-apartment in the sky.  Whilst the Emirates seat does have a sliding door, it is really a novelty – it is no higher than the seat and everyone walking past can see over it – and I have never closed it.  BA doesn’t lose any points from me by not having doors on their seat.

IFE

The TV and IFE selection are particularly poor.  It is unlikely that BA will ever be able to match the sheer scale of the selection offered by the Middle East carriers – 2,500 channels on Emirates and 3,000 on Qatar Airways – and even if they did you’d be watching it on a smaller TV.

(I tried to get some comparable screen size numbers but airlines appear to measure their screens in different ways.  BA’s screen is described as 23 inches whilst the Etihad First Class Apartment one is described as 24 inches despite being around twice the size!)

As you can see from this picture, British Airways First Class isn’t really a ‘big screen’ experience although it does the job:

British Airways First Class review

British Airways does not have in-flight wi-fi but it is on the way.  In theory, when fully active later this year, it should be an improvement on what Emirates and Etihad offers because it is using a newer generation of equipment.  Pricing will not be cheap whilst Emirates is a nominal $1.

The bathroom

There is nothing to say about the British Airways First Class bathroom.

The flower had not even been put back when we flew at the end of April, although it should be in place now.

No shower.  At least that means there isn’t another HFP in-shower video to watch!

Bedding

I was offered a sleep suit by the crew but turned it down, because history shows that these are not designed for normal people!  Anyone weighing less than 20 stones is likely to find the waistband falling down whenever they stand up.

The Etihad First Class Apartment one was not much better.  Emirates did not offer me pyjamas on a First Class day flight, although for overnight flights you can test out “our new pyjamas [which] use Hydra Active Microcapsule Technology to keep your skin soft while flying”.

My duvet was found in the overhead locker.  I had to track this down myself.

British Airways First Class review

I don’t sleep on day flights and this one was no exception.  In general I find the British Airways First Class seat comfortable and, given that I am 6’2′, long enough.  If you are in a window seat you are effectively sitting in a triangular space whilst the middle seats – see the TV picture above – are rectangular and have substantially more foot room.

In Part 2 of this British Airways First Class review (click here) I take a look at the food and drink on offer in British Airways First Class.  Perhaps surprisingly, BA does not collapse in the face of Emirates and Etihad.

(Want to earn more Avios?  Click here to visit our home page for the latest articles on earning and spending your Avios points and click here to see how to earn more Avios from current offers and promotions.)

BA launches European luxury beach holidays flash sale (ends Monday)
How does BA First Class really compare to Emirates or Etihad? (Part 2)
About Head for Points

We help business and leisure travellers maximise their Avios, frequent flyer miles and hotel loyalty points. Visit every day for three new articles or sign up for our FREE emails via this page or the box to your right.

Comments

  1. More space on QR business class?! I’ve never reading anything much more misleading!

    It’s simply not the case, the BA F seat takes up around 30% more space on the plane.

    I also find that the medium BA PJs fit my 33 inch, 13 stone frame more than fine, there are certainly my no issues with them falling down, indeed O sadly do not need to use he string to tighten!

    • It’s not ‘more space’, it is purely bed / seat size and ignores personal space.

      • Fair enough if just talking about the ‘seat’. I suspect if you took full surface area as opposed to just length and width, it would again be considerably bigger.

        In reality, unless you’re a very large member of society, its more than big enough and the actual feeling of space is far more important.

        Something where BA F easily trumps most of the business seats referenced (bar maybe on the 747 where it’s still clearly ahead however)

  2. MaxMaxMax says:

    What is this concept of “Britishness” you speak of? I honestly don’t understand how that translates into an aircraft seat design.

    Unless you are referring to delusions of grandeur leading to a vote which did not make sense, inciting xenophobia and now a country which with every passing day appears more dysfunctional?

    • More negativity…….go away…….the UK is fantastic and I like BA.

    • The design idea behind F is a high end luxury car, a Jag / Bentley / Aston Martin. That is the ‘Britishness’ I was thinking about.

      This is, of course, very much a ‘Britishness of the mind’ since only a handful of people actually drive such cars or hang out in Mayfair / St James clubs, but that is the idea.

      I think Tyler Brule of Monocle magazine did the current F cabin.

      • Ruth Findlay says:

        Did he? Well it ought to be good then, he’s a man of taste. I’m about to book two F seats to HND – looking forward to checking out my first F experience. Quick question though – for a couple is it generally better to go for two single seats at the window or two middle seats?

        • Frankly my wife and I have no interest in talking to each other for 12 hours and so we take two window seats behind each other. Unless you’re on honeymoon you would be fine to do the same 🙂

        • Genghis says:

          +1

        • +1

          even worse are those CW seats that face each other. We book 2 forward facing aisle seats!

        • Ruth Findlay says:

          Well this will be our 20th wedding anniversary so two window seats will be fine! ☺️

  3. I think this is a very fair review. I like the cabin, I like the seat and it’s definitely a great J product. First however is more than this. I know crew with 30 years service and they simply cringe at what is offered today compared to what offered in the past.
    With 18 seats they carved the beef, provided chateaux Talbot and it was fabulous. No one could compete. The crew were knowledgable, professional and worldly and could communicate.
    I was sat beside a UK sports minister returning from Singapore and he and I were showered in Champagne when the crew spilt a whole tray of ore takeoff drinks into his lap. There was little fuss but calm professional approach. The CSD attended and everyone was fine. He spent much of flight sitting on the floor under the screen ( it was a long time ago) chatting to his colleagues in 1EF.
    Today the crew are incapable of making a martini, so they removed Vermouth! They are not dedicated, receive minimal training and so badly paid that many have second jobs.
    First should be an experience, not an endurance and flying long haul BA, even on Avios is now a chore, spending real money on it is madness

  4. Agreed Rob. The worst seats are where your feet go into a trapped box. CW screens are shocking but tilt when you lie down so you can see the screen properly. Not possible with F and most others actually (happy to be corrected if other airlines have screens that can tilt when you lay down watching).

    • VS ones can tilt too 🙂 Also all-aisle access, although having to specifically flip it into bed is a slight pain cf BA…

  5. JamesB says:

    OT but BA. Find myself needing to go to USA for first time in over seven years, I was checking one way CW redemption back from SFO to EDI via LHR in CW. It came in at 62500 avios plus £405 tax and fees. Are the tax and fees correct, seemed very high to me? Going out I fancy a couple of nights in Dublin before taking advantage of customs preclearance on a trip to east coast. What are the best value options, Aer Lingus or AA? Might even consider going out in economy as flights are daytime and not too long.

    • Taxes are FAR higher if you start your trip in the US. This makes a one way fairly painful.

      Try airberlin (£4 tax one way) or Aer Lingus (probably £20 or so) – although the latter is tough to get.

      • Although possibly just well they’re priced liked that or the Avios mountains readily accessible to US customers would suck up a lot of the availability!

    • JamesB says:

      Thanks guys. I will look for Aer Lingus option but otherwise will just grin and bear it with BA (I may have option to keep costs lowet on outward leg exDUB). Needs to be SFO so AA or AN less attractive as those mean an extra sector. On the plus side I can get my £100 amex offer (As there will be two of us), the LHR layover is only 90 minutes, and it’s another chance to fly the a380.

  6. Darren says:

    Re the seat dimensions – I had an issue with the Emirates 380, cramped (the numbers explain this) and that mini bar thing is very poorly designed with rubbish materials, but I liked their 777 config out of NCL.

  7. “Given that I am 6’2″ long…”

    That *is* quite long!

  8. Re the toiletries – if they give my 11 year old crayons in CW again this summer, can I ask them to swap them for mini potions? He doesn’t want either but the toiletries would be of much more use to me!

  9. Andrew Lyons says:

    i agree with most of the review, the First Class lounge is poor here bt overall the product is good. I must take issues with the comments regarding athe toiletries and any body who has actually tried to use them has my full sympathy. The bag is a cheap flimsy affair. In the mens it contains a mini stick deodarant that is almost impossible to use, it is too small and falls to pieces if you ever actually try and use it!

    The razor blade is poor but worst of all is the “shaving gel” that does not lather, perhaps it is a lubricating gel rather than shaving gel! I would rate the Emirates business toileteries as 5 and this First offering as a very poor 1 !

    • I like the Rituals shaving gel, it works fine for me.

      I agree that the deo always falls out of the holder, but it still functions ….

  10. “unsurpriSIngly”…

  11. Btw, how did you manage to secure FOUR redemptions on one flight???