Earn American Airlines miles (plus Etihad, Lufthansa) writing reviews for HolidayCheck

This article is closed to new comments. Feel free to ask your question in the HfP forums.

• Fenny says:

  21 Feb21 February 08:03

  I could bash out a dozen or so from my last couple of years’ holidays.

• mark2 says:

  21 Feb21 February 08:34

  If you have already entered reports onto Tripadvisor just copy and paste them across.

  • Ed says:

    21 Feb21 February 08:59

    Or copy and paste anyone’s review from tripadvisor?

    • Pat Butcher says:

      21 Feb21 February 09:45

      They ask for proof of stay.

• Ed says:

  21 Feb21 February 09:03

  By my calculations you could generate 18k Etihad miles from reviews per year? This seems quite a lucrative possibility. Do any of these schemes have a BA style household account, thinking my auntie, uncle, sister, brother dog and milkman who joined me on holiday might want to write a review?

  • Rob says:

    21 Feb21 February 10:31

    Etihad certainly does, I have written about it in the past. A friend of mine cleaned up when his parents and extended family (but not him) went to The Maldives and he took all the miles.

• Danksy says:

  21 Feb21 February 09:44

  I did a review a while back and they did say that they vett the reviews and may ask for proof that you stayed where you said you did!

  • Fenny says:

    21 Feb21 February 11:18

    I’m assuming a booking confirmation email will suffice, if required. I keep mine for years!

• Paul says:

  21 Feb21 February 12:17

  I’ve earned a couple of thousand so far in lufthansa. Nice lttle bonus for miles that are harder to earn. I have been asked to provide proof of stay a few times so they do check.

• Tom euflyer says:

  21 Feb21 February 18:54

  While the ethics are dubious, the proof of stay request (which is regularly required) for reviews where a stay has not actually been made can be overcome with a refundable/cancellable booking that is then refunded/cancelled. You’ll still get a confirmation email at the time of booking of course.

  • Brian says:

    21 Feb21 February 20:26

    Sounds like a lot of hassle for 70 p worth of miles, especially considering the ethical aspect!

    • Tom euflyer says:

      22 Feb22 February 10:50

      Agreed, although I wouldn’t want to admit to some of the lengths I’ve gone to in the past for a handful of miles.

      In any event, unless it’s the only scheme of use to you, you’d be ill-advised to go for the 70 AA miles for holidaycheck reviews when there’s alternatively 100 M&M and 150 Etihad Guest/Topbonus miles available.

      • Pierre says:

        26 Feb26 February 05:03

        I personally value more 70 AA miles than 100MM miles. American has definitly the best program. You can have flight with very little taxes departing from Europe for less miles. But the real value is the ability to give another 18 months easily as Raffles pointed.
        I did a review and I wasn’t asked any proof. Maybe they start asking after many reviews in a row.

  • John says:

    21 Feb21 February 22:12

    Easiest thing is to only review hotels you actually stay at. This makes for a useful website (in contrast to the all too often unreliable trip advisor).

    In my experience collecting air berlin tb points, holidaycheck (very politely) ask for proof once every eight or so reviews. It takes about 30 seconds to forward the booking confirmation email.

    As Tom above has indicated, this doesn’t absolutely guarantee reviews are genuine, but I think it’s reasonable for the site to attempt some form of verification from time to time.

• signol says:

  21 Feb21 February 22:09

  Has anyone else noticed Etihad’s current status match offer?

  • Rob says:

    21 Feb21 February 22:27

    Yes, will onto this early next week. Only useful in a very particular set of circumstances (unless you can match it to Gold elsewhere!).

• Stuart says:

  23 Feb23 February 12:31

  Correct me if I’m wrong but all those miles will expire regardless of activity on the account after a few years (depending on the airline) with the exception of AA which you can keep alive with things like this?

  • Rob says:

    23 Feb23 February 15:08

    Etihad will expire. Miles & More will expire UNLESS you have the UK Miles & More credit card (free) and use it once a month. AA will not expire as long as you have activity of any sort every 18 months.

This article is closed to new comments. Feel free to ask your question in the HfP forums.