Why did I fly both Emirates A380 First and Etihad A380 First within 72 hours?

I thought I’d run this as a fourth ‘bonus’ article – it has not gone to the email list – since it simply sets the scene for a series of articles on my recent whistle-stop trip to the Middle East which starts tomorrow.  This is basically a comparison of Etihad’s A380 First Class Apartment and Emirates A380 First Class.

It is an attempt to show what it being done at the top of the market by other airlines – although you will discover that neither product manages to get everything right.

Jumeirah Zabeel Saray

As usual with major HFP review trips, there were multiple reasons for doing it.  The clock was counting down on my 60,000 Etihad Guest miles.  These were going to expire in the Autumn and there is no way of extending their life.  I decided to top them up with some American Express Membership Rewards points and redeem for a First Class Apartment seat.

I was also aware that I had never reviewed Emirates A380 First Class on Head for Points.  I have only flown it once and that was eight years ago.  I also wanted to check out the First Classs ‘floor’ they built in Dubai International.

(Concourse A in Dubai Terminal 3 has 3 levels.  Instead of lounges, the public uses the ground floor, Business Class passengers get the entire second floor – which is as long as the terminal itself – and First Class passengers get the entire 1st floor.  Combined, these floors are probably bigger than every single airport lounge I have been in over the last 25 years added together.)

Again, an Amex Membership Rewards transfer allowed me to pick up the necessary Skywards miles and make a one-way booking.

I also had an accommodation offer on the table.  When I was on holiday in Dubai last year I met up with a representative of the Jumeirah Zabeel Saray resort on The Palm.

I had stayed there back in 2012 but much has changed and they offered me a few free nights if I wanted to take another look.  Restrictions on the dates that I could choose meant that it wasn’t suitable for a family holiday but it would give me a base for this trip.

Jumeirah gave me three free nights bed and breakfast, together with lounge access.  Whilst I was grateful for the free room, it didn’t influence my opinion and my conclusions are roughly the same as those I drew when I stayed four years ago and paid cash.

More to follow on this throughout the week, as we wind down towards the long Easter weekend.

(Want to earn more Avios?  Click here to visit our home page for the latest articles on earning and spending your Avios points and click here to see how to earn more Avios from current offers and promotions.)

What is the best hotel scheme? - Hilton Honors - The Facts
Bits: last call for Nutmeg / Avios deal, £1000 Virgin Upper Class to Boston, new Norwegian routes
About Head for Points

We help business and leisure travellers maximise their Avios, frequent flyer miles and hotel loyalty points. Visit every day for three new articles or sign up for our FREE emails via this page or the box to your right.


  1. Looking forward to this!